Police RELEASE drone couple after Gatwick chaos

Aviation
image_pdfimage_print

The couple accused of being behind the Gatwick drone chaos have today been released by police without charge.

Paul Gait, a double-glazing fitter, and his wife Elaine, from Crawley in West Sussex, have been released after being questioned by police over the drone that brought Gatwick to a standstill and ruined Christmas for more than 140,000 air passengers.

The pair returned to their family home in Crawley this morning after spending some 36 hours in police custody.

 Gatwick Airport is now offering a £50,000 reward to catch the culprit who operated the drone which grounded more than 1,000 flights.

Questions have now been raised as to why ministers refused to sanction the deployment of a crack team of military electronic warfare specialists who could have brought the drone crisis to a halt just hours after it started.

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine, 54, arriving home on Sunday morning after spending 36 hours in police custody

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine, 54, arriving home on Sunday morning after spending 36 hours in police custody

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54, both from Crawley, were arrested in the town shortly after 10pm on Friday. They were released without charge on Sunday morning

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54, both from Crawley, were arrested in the town shortly after 10pm on Friday. They were released without charge on Sunday morning

Mr Gait, a model aircraft enthusiast, once posted this picture of a toy helicopter on Facebook

Mr Gait, a model aircraft enthusiast, once posted this picture of a toy helicopter on Facebook

Neighbours had described how model aircraft enthusiast Gait was regularly seen flying remote controlled cars, drones and planes near the detached property he lives in, which is just one mile from the runway where more than 1,000 flights have been affected since Wednesday night.

Yesterday, neighbours expressed the view that police had simply got the wrong couple, with some suggesting that the pressure to get results had led to hasty arrests.

Relief for Christmas holidaymakers as Gatwick gets back to normal

Gatwick Airport today confirmed its runway is open and it aims to run a full schedule this weekend.

A spokesman told MailOnline services are ‘stable and normal’.

Only one flight this evening has been cancelled – a domestic flight to Stansted Airport which should not affect passengers.

There are some 769 flights operating today, with a total of 131, 228 passengers passing through Gatwick.

This includes some 73,726 holidaymakers departing on outbound flights and 57,502 passengers coming through arrivals.

However passengers are being warned they should expect some delays as the airport continues to ‘recover our operations’ following three days of disruption.

Holidaymakers are advised to check with their airline before travelling to the airport.

Click here for live travel information 

Officers from Sussex Police today remain outside the couple’s detached house in a quiet cul de sac less than a mile from Gatwick’s runway.

As the couple were brought home in a police van escorted by two police cars, they declined to comment on allegations that drone enthusiast Mr Gait had been responsible for closing down Gatwick Airport.

His parents had insisted their son was a ‘nice boy’ who would ‘simply not have had the time’ to carry out the attack.

Sussex Police Detective Chief Superintendent Jason Tingley said today: ‘Both people have fully co-operated with our enquiries and I am satisfied that they are no longer suspects in the drone incidents at Gatwick.

‘It is important to remember that when people are arrested in an effort to make further enquiries it does not mean that they are guilty of an offence and Sussex Police would not seek to make their identity public.

‘Our inquiry continues at a pace to locate those responsible for the drone incursions, and we continue to actively follow lines of investigation.

‘We ask for the public’s continued support by reporting anything suspicious, contacting us with any information in relation to the drone incidents at Gatwick.’

Gatwick Airport Limited has offered a £50,000 reward through Crimestoppers, for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible for the criminal act that disrupted flights.

If you have any information please contact Crimestoppers 100% anonymously on 0800 555 111 or through their anonymous online form at Crimestoppers website. Payout on the reward will be made only if the information is given to Crimestoppers first.

Speaking from their Kent home, Paul’s parents Margaret and Francis, who are in their 70s, emphatically defended their son, claiming: ‘There is no way he would ever put anyone’s life in danger.’

The 47-year-old’s mother Margaret said her son was a ‘nice person’ and the drone attack was just ‘not the sort of thing he would do.’

His father Francis added: ‘He was brave and served his country, and always did as he was asked.

‘And it has been said eco-warriors might be behind it – but he’s no eco-warrior,’ he added. ‘He likes to fish and he likes his meat. Everyone is phoning me up and saying, ‘It can’t be him. That’s not Paul.’

‘He has never been in trouble. He had a big model helicopter but he sold that a couple of years ago. He has had small drones. Somebody has pointed the finger at him and said, ‘He likes to fly drones’. But Paul wouldn’t do something like this.’

Search for evidence: Police in Crawley this morning where the couple were arrested on Friday night in the wake of the Gatwick Airport chaos which left hundreds of thousands of holidaymakers stranded just days before Christmas 

Search for evidence: Police in Crawley this morning where the couple were arrested on Friday night in the wake of the Gatwick Airport chaos which left hundreds of thousands of holidaymakers stranded just days before Christmas

Gemma Allard had an eight-year relationship with Mr Gait and is the mother of his 15-year-old sonGemma, 40, and her father run Allard Double Glazing in Crowborough, where Paul works

Gemma, 40, and her father run Allard Double Glazing in Crowborough, where Paul works

Gemma Allard had an eight-year relationship with Mr Gait and is the mother of his 15-year-old son. Gemma, 40, and her father run Allard Double Glazing in Crowborough, where Paul works. She maintained his innocence

Mr Gait works for a double-glazing company, Allard Windows, in Crowborough, East Sussex

Mr Gait works for a double-glazing company, Allard Windows, in Crowborough, East Sussex

Paul Gait, a double-glazing fitter, and his wife Elaine, from Crawley in West Sussex, today returned to their family home

Paul Gait, a double-glazing fitter, and his wife Elaine, from Crawley in West Sussex, today returned to their family home

At their Kent home last night, Mr Gait’s parents, who are in their 70s, watched in sheer disbelief the 6pm TV news, which included film of their son’s home being searched.

Close to tears, his father slowly shook his head. Beside him his wife, wide-eyed, pressed her hand over her mouth. She said: ‘We’re in total shock. We can’t believe it.’

‘He was brave and served his country, and always did as he was asked,’ his father said. ‘There is no way he would ever put anyone’s life in danger.’

Neighbour Bob Simpkin, 74, saw Mr Gait being carted away in a van by police late on Friday night.

‘Suddenly I heard screaming and shouting. I went out to see what was going on, and I saw a man being taken away,’ he said.

‘I thought it was rowdy behaviour from youngsters. Not in a million years could I have imagined what it was really about.’

Paul’s father told us that his son joined the Army straight from school. A gunner in the Royal Artillery, he did two tours of Northern Ireland and a stint in Bosnia during the war in the early 1990s.

‘He was brave and served his country, and always did as he was asked,’ his father said.

‘There is no way he would ever put anyone’s life in danger.’

After leaving the Army, Mr Gait worked as a security guard for the council in Tunbridge Wells, Kent, where he monitored the town’s CCTV cameras. If he witnessed suspicious or any anti-social behaviour, his job was to alert Kent Police.

An officer checks the boot of a car as police carried out their investigation

Paul Gait and his wife Elaine (pictured together) were arrested on Friday but Mr Gait's boss said he was at work and could not have been the culprit

Paul Gait and his wife Elaine (pictured together) were arrested on Friday but Mr Gait's boss said he was at work and could not have been the culprit

An officer checks the boot of a car (left) as police carried out their investigation. Paul Gait and his wife Elaine (pictured together right) were arrested on Friday but Mr Gait’s boss said he was at work and could not have been the culprit

Mr Gait now works for a double-glazing company, Allard Windows, in Crowborough, East Sussex.

His Facebook profile depicts him as an easy-going, hands-on dad who likes tinkering with toy planes.

He lists ‘radio-controlled flying’ as one of his interests and ‘planes’ as another. Two years ago, he reviewed drone company Vifly on Facebook, noting that ‘the quality of the kits are amazing’ and ‘I look forward to dealing with them in the new year.’

His father insisted that his son would simply not have had time to carry out the Gatwick attacks because he was at work all week.

Others painted a similar portrait. Gemma Allard had an eight-year relationship with Mr Gait and is the mother of his 15-year-old son.

Gemma, 40, and her father run Allard Double Glazing in Crowborough, where Paul works.

She said: ‘When it [the drone attack] started, Paul was sitting in my front room in Crowborough having a cup of tea, and the rest of the day he was working at my clients’ houses. So he was not even near Gatwick – he was 17 miles away.

‘I know what they [the police] are doing – they are trying to do something to please the public, but they have got the wrong man, and they need to let him out and catch the people behind this.

A model plane enthusiast, Paul Gait offered this radio-controlled Second World War fighter for sale on Facebook. He sold the model of an American P-51C Mustang, above, for £200 in July 2017 - telling buyers to 'collect from Gatwick'

A model plane enthusiast, Paul Gait offered this radio-controlled Second World War fighter for sale on Facebook. He sold the model of an American P-51C Mustang, above, for £200 in July 2017 – telling buyers to ‘collect from Gatwick’

‘He is not a drone enthusiast, he is a model aircraft enthusiast. He had a drone, but he has not got a drone at present, and he was that far away. The police don’t want to hear it because then they’ll have hard evidence [that he didn’t do it] and they don’t want to release him. They want to keep the public happy.’

What is the law on drones? Who can buy them and how flying too close to an airport can land you five years in prison

The major flight disruption at London Gatwick today comes just five months after new laws banned drones from flying too close to airports.

Legislation implemented in July means people in Britain are now banned from flying the devices above 400ft and within 1km (0.6 miles) of airport boundaries.

Drone users who flout the height and airport boundary restrictions could face an unlimited fine, up to five years in prison, or both.

Laws introduced to the Commons in May mean people flying drones which weigh 250g or more will have to register with the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA).

Drone pilots will be required to take an online safety test under the new legislation, with the requirements set to come into force in November next year.

Research has found a drone weighing 400g (14oz) could smash a helicopter windscreen, and one at 2kg (4lbs) could critically damage an airliner’s windscreen.

In July, the DfT said it was considering introducing an age restriction, banning children from owning drones weighing at least 250g.

It also said it was considering giving police the power to issue on-the-spot fines of up to £300 for misuse and the ability to seize drones being used irresponsibly.

There have already been 117 near misses between manned aircraft and drones up until November this year, compared to 93 for the whole of 2017.

She suspects that someone ‘with a bone to pick with him’ maliciously tipped off police about him having a drone.

She added: ‘I was in a relationship with Paul for eight years and I’ve known him since 2000, Paul wouldn’t do this, not a chance, he was sitting in our office in Crowborough.

‘I’ve gone to the police, the custody suite said they might get back to me, my belief is that they don’t want to get back to me as they know he wasn’t there.

‘Paul hasn’t even got a drone at the minute, I think somebody with a bone to pick with him has gone to the police.

‘They’ve said to them ‘this guy lives near Gatwick Airport and he has had a drone’ – I wouldn’t name who I think that’s said it, but I think that’s one potential.

‘Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday he works for me, obviously we’ve got a son together too, so he comes in about seven o’clock for a cup of tea.

‘Paul works for me as a double glazing installer, he goes straight to mine, has a cup of tea and leaves about quarter to eight for the office.

‘Numerous people at work would have seen him as well as clients at their houses – he was with two other of our employees and the last time I saw him was at three o’clock on Friday in Crowborough,

‘To the people that did this at Gatwick, they need locking up, we need some sort of regulation, it’s ridiculous how in this day and age we can’t do anything to stop them.’

Gemma and another employee from Allard Double Glazing were quizzed by detectives at Crawley police station last night.

She said: ‘Two employees are able to vouch for him and they have done. I was the main witness because I was with him in the morning, he was on site with two people.

‘An apprentice who worked with Paul has been interviewed and corroborated by statement. He doesn’t have drones, he is the father of my child, I hear all about his helicopters.

‘Paul sold his drone so he could buy a helicopter – he has never had a four foot drone. Besides that old drone he had was no more than a foot long, it just made a little buzzing sound – he got rid of that months ago.’

Others defended Mr Gait’s wife Elaine, whom he married in 2013. She has worked in sales for Unilever for the past 20 years. Her ex-husband Ian Kirk said: ‘There is no way that Elaine could do this. She hates drones and she cannot even operate them.’

A former Unilever colleague added: ‘She’s a sweet, quiet lady who has a son who she adores. I can’t see her being involved.’

Mr Gait’s boss John Allard vouched for him and said he was at work. Mr Allard, who runs a double glazing firm in Crowborough, said he could ‘account for Paul’s movements between the hours of 7am and 5pm last Monday to Friday’.

The 47-year-old former suspect had been ‘part of a three-man team fitting glass doors and windows in the Crowborough area’, his employer said.

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54, both from Crawley, were arrested in the town shortly after 10pm on Friday. They were released without charge on Sunday

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54, both from Crawley, were arrested in the town shortly after 10pm on Friday. They were released without charge on Sunday

Paul Gait (right) and his wife Elaine (left) pictured out with a friend for drinks in a pub

Paul Gait (right) and his wife Elaine (left) pictured out with a friend for drinks in a pub

Speaking to the Telegraph, Mr Allard added: ‘He is a reliable family man who has been with me for 17 years and has never given me any problems at all.

‘He may have picked up the interest in model flying from me because I’ve been doing it for 40 years.’

Mr Allard added: ‘I also know Paul’s wife Elaine and as far as I know she has no interest at all in drones or model flying.’

Police were also looking into theories as to whether eco-warriors or a group of activists protesting deportations of migrants could be behind the drone mayhem.

Crawley, a town with a population of just over 100,000, is just five miles away from Gatwick and under the airport’s flightpath.

Activists in the town have previously declared a ‘state of emergency’ in the countryside to counter a proposed second runway.

Around 1,000 aircraft have been cancelled or diverted amid this week’s mayhem, plunging 140,000 passengers into chaos since Wednesday night.

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54,

Paul Gait, 47, and his wife Elaine Kirk, 54,

The couple (left and right) live just five miles away from the airport. Paul Gait is a window fitter and his boss has said he was working at the time of the incident

Neighbours of the couple have said they would 'be surprised' if they had anything to do with the incident

Neighbours of the couple have said they would ‘be surprised’ if they had anything to do with the incident

Counter drone equipment was deployed on a rooftop at Gatwick airport, as the airport and airlines work to clear the backlog caused by the incident 

Counter drone equipment was deployed on a rooftop at Gatwick airport, as the airport and airlines work to clear the backlog caused by the incident

Passengers queue up for news regarding their easyJet flights on Saturday morning (pictured). Around 1,000 aircraft have been cancelled or diverted, affecting approximately 140,000 passengers since Wednesday night, a Gatwick spokesman said

Passengers queue up for news regarding their easyJet flights on Saturday morning (pictured). Around 1,000 aircraft have been cancelled or diverted, affecting approximately 140,000 passengers since Wednesday night, a Gatwick spokesman said

Bob Simpkin, 74, said: ‘Paul is what you could describe as an average person, a hard working builder. I was shocked to hear what happened, I do believe the police have got the wrong people – this is totally out of character.

‘Last night I heard a lot of screaming and shouting, when I looked outside I saw a woman being led to a police van by a female copper.

‘The van was parked outside their house and I saw a woman led into the van. Paul and Elaine have been together for about five years – I sometimes see a young lad of about ten there too.

‘Elaine doesn’t seem the person to get involved in any trouble – she works a lot too from what I can tell. Were they the couple who flew the drone at the airport? I don’t think so.

‘Paul is just not stupid enough to do that – I’ve got the feeling the police are wrong. He is more into his model helicopters, I’ve seen him use them, but only around his property.’

Another neighbour, who wished not to be named, said: ‘They don’t seem the type to do this, they’re down to earth. He’s a builder and she works somewhere six days a week.

‘Paul likes his gadgets, he only ever used his drone in the street – you could hear all that buzzing sound. I haven’t seen them use it recently but its winter so it’s dark.

‘He used to do it in the street, everyone was quite impressed, especially the kids. They keep themselves to themselves really.’

Another neighbour said: ‘Paul is a hard working family man, it is unbelievable. These are just two lovely people that met dog walking and worked six days a week.’

A worker can been seen on the roof top at Gatwick airport, after fitting counter drone equipment to the roof

A worker can been seen on the roof top at Gatwick airport, after fitting counter drone equipment to the roof

The arrests come as police look into theories as to whether eco-warriors or a group of activists protesting deportations of migrants could be behind the drone mayhem. A police car leaving Crawley police station this morning (pictured) 

The arrests come as police look into theories as to whether eco-warriors or a group of activists protesting deportations of migrants could be behind the drone mayhem. A police car leaving Crawley police station this morning (pictured)

The suspects: Who could have carried out the drone attack?

Environmental activist group: Groups such as Extinction Rebellion and Plane Stupid have been carrying out increasingly high-profile stunts in recent months, but no one has claimed responsibility over yesterday’s action.

Speaking to MailOnline, an Extinction Rebellion spokesman said the group had nothing to do with the drone. She added that the police had not been in contact with them about the incident at Gatwick.

‘Lone wolf’: The incident may be the work of an anarchistic loner who wanted to make an impact and cause carnage.

Foreign power: Some experts say the sophistication of the equipment used suggests a hostile foreign government may be involved.

Anti-noise campaigners: It is possible a local resident with a grudge against aircraft noise carried out the drone flights in retaliation at the airport.

Immigration campaigners: In the wake of convictions of the ‘Stansted 15’ earlier this month, a case involving activists who stopped a deportation flight, it is possible a copycat campaigner tried to stop a planned deportation.

Extortionist: Some have suggested an extortionist could be using the financial damage caused by the drone flight to extort money out of one of the many businesses hurt.

Mr Gait is also said to have fallen out with his next door neighbour over a boundary issue.

A friend of his told MailOnline: ‘Paul told me that his neighbour’s hedge was quite overgrown and that he was having difficulty parking his van.

‘He said that he’d asked the neighbour if he could trim the hedge back slightly but he refused and so they didn’t speak again after that.

‘Paul said that people would ask if they could have a go on his drone or helicopter when they saw him flying but he told me ‘there’s no way I’d allow that as these things can be dangerous in the wrong hands’

‘I haven’t seen Paul or Elaine all day. They have two dogs, a Jack Russell and a pug, which they take out for walks every day but we’ve not seen them at all.

‘From what I know of him, I’d be staggered if he’s the one responsible for crippling Gatwick and causing all that chaos.’

Last night motorist Paul Motts, 52, revealed he saw a man in his 30s wearing hi-vis clothing and crouching over a drone in a country lane near the West Sussex airport on Thursday.

Mr Motts said the suspicious man had been trying to ‘get away as fast as he could’ as Sussex Police combed the countryside to find the drone pilot.

He told The Sun: ‘I was delivering a parcel and drove past a suspicious man in fluorescent cycling gear crouching over a large drone which was all lit up.

‘It looked like he was packing the drones away. Two minutes later we turned around and came across him cycling away.

‘I expect he wanted to disassemble the drone as quickly as possible and get away as fast as he could.’

Crawley is just over five miles away from Gatwick, the UK's busiest airport which sees hundreds of flights leave to and from the transport hub every day

Crawley is just over five miles away from Gatwick, the UK’s busiest airport which sees hundreds of flights leave to and from the transport hub every day

Another neighbour, speaking from a home illuminated by neon Christmas lights and tinsel, described seeing Paul Gait operating a remote-controlled car, Jeep and a small helicopter.

The man, who did not want to be named, said: ‘I remember laughing one time because I thought he was going to crash it, I don’t think he knew what he was doing, he was driving this remote controlled Jeep in the street.

‘He had a helicopter or a model plane too. I remember thinking ‘look at that big kid with his toys’!’

A Gatwick spokesman said earlier: ‘Many people will be due to fly today and there will be longer delays perhaps.

‘But broadly things are going in the right direction. By the end of the weekend, things should be back to normal.’

On Saturday, the queue for check-ins stretched the length of the departures hall – while a heavy stream of passengers poured through the arrivals gates as a full schedule of flights operated.

Passengers sit and wait for more information regarding their flights this morning, as many flights still have delays on Saturday

A girl sits

A girl sits

Passengers sit and wait for more information regarding their flights this morning, as many flights still have delays on Saturday

Timeline: How dangerous drone pilot managed to shut down Gatwick

Police are hunting for the expert drone pilot who has grounded hundreds of planes coming in and out of Gatwick by flying a drone at least 50 times

Here is how the chaos has unfolded:

9pm, December 19: Drone is first spotted by airport staff hovering near the runway causing flights to be grounded or diverted.

9.15pm: It appears again leading Gatwick bosses to believe it is a deliberate act.

9.30pm – midnight: The drone is seen at least five more times in that period

3.01am, December 20: Airport re-opens its runway after the all clear is given

3.45am: Drone is seen again and flights are again grounded

7am: Small unmanned aircraft appears again

9am: Another sighting of the drone as police start hunting perimeter of the airport

Midday: Police are unable find the drone pilot despite it appearing again at lunchtime with Gatwick saying all flights are grounded until at least 4pm

2pm: Airport admits it has ‘no idea’ when it will re-open as police struggle to find the pilot

3pm: The drone is spotted again as it buzzes across Gatwick’s runway. It was just minutes after airport bosses announced they had hoped to re-open at 4pm.

4pm: Drone spotted flying over the runway yet again.

5pm: Ministry of Defence confirms that it is using specialist equipment to seek out the drone

8pm: Gatwick tells passengers not to come to the airport on Friday as drone buzzes across terminals

8.30pm-9.30pm: Another sighting of the drone on Thursday evening

10pm: The last known sighting of the drone hours after Army is deployed

3am, Friday December 21: Airport bosses deem the airspace is clear

6am: Gatwick re-opens the runway

10.30am: Flights are taking off and landing as normal

5.10pm: The runway is closed again after another suspected sighting

10pm: Two suspects are arrested, Sussex Police announce

December 23: Sussex Police confirm two suspects arrested in conjunction with the widespread disruption of flights at Gatwick Airport through the illegal use of drones have been released without charge

In the departures line was the Shorrock family, from Oxford, who were flying to Innsbruck in the Austrian Alps for a skiing trip.

Vivienne Shorrock was ‘relieved’ to have avoided the drone disruption as she was worried the family’s non-refundable holiday would go to waste.

‘But then we thought well it’s a middle class problem isn’t it. Oh no, we can’t go on a skiing holiday,’ she said.

‘In perspective some people have suffered real losses by not getting where they want to go to be with family.’

David Shorrock joked the drone drama was a ‘nice distraction from Brexit’ before offering a novel solution to the problem.

‘They should’ve got some farmers here. They would’ve soon sorted it out,’ he said.

‘You get 100 young farmers here with a flagon of cider. Free cider for anyone who shoots the drone.’

Planes were grounded again at 5pm on Friday when a drone was sighted above the airfield before air traffic resumed with severe delays.

One flight from Morocco appeared to be just moments away from landing when it was forced to divert only 1,000 feet above the ground last night while other passengers were sitting ready for take-off when pilots told them of another sighting.

Just over an hour later Gatwick said planes had returned to the air, saying the ‘military measures in place at the airport’ would ensure the safety of passengers.

The Army had earlier used jamming devices in the hope of knocking the drone out of the sky as police scoured the Sussex countryside in a bit to find the culprit.

Police said they were closing in on the pilots who allegedly used ‘multiple’ drones to shut down Gatwick’s runway and are even claimed to have taunted officers by zooming over their heads while flashing lights at them.

Passengers were left with Christmas plans ruined, with some forced to abandon holidays abroad while others struggled to return to the UK in time for December 25.

One had to fork out thousands of dollars for a one-way ticket from New York to get back to the UK from New York after her flight could not reach Gatwick on Friday morning.

Scarlette Tidy was booked on a Norwegian Air flight to Gatwick but by the time she was told the trip was cancelled, all the airline’s flights to London were sold out until after Christmas.

With passengers waiting two hours for a ‘live chat’ on Norwegian’s website she was forced to spend over $3,000 – several times what she had originally paid – to reach her family in time for Christmas.

She said the experience had been a ‘total disaster’ but that she was now en route back to London.

Another passenger, Emma Jewell, told MailOnline she and her boyfriend were stranded in the Dominican Republic after her flight to Gatwick had been cancelled.

She said the airline had rebooked them on a flight to Heathrow via Philadelphia, but her boyfriend’s ESTA for the United States did not come through in time and they could not board the flight.

The couple then boarded a flight to New York only to find there was a problem with the air conditioning, leaving them waiting on the tarmac and certain to miss their connection to the UK.

Related Posts

Average Rating
0 out of 5 stars. 0 votes.
My Rating: